I had high hopes Saturday night when I hunkered down, with your cookbook in hand, to make a special birthday celebration using your recipes… yes high hopes indeed. I could have picked any cookbook and any recipes to make, but I choose you, Mr Dobson. Your book “Market Vegetarian” with its gorgeous photography which set the bar to expect spectacular results…. hmmm Mr Dobson what have you to say when my comments are, “I would have been better off pulling something from my own culinary repertoire” and “how could you write something that has NO SALT in it at all? Surely this is just an editing mistake?
All that effort, all those ingredients, all my concentration to actually follow the recipe! This did me no justice and I was excited to try these two out. First up a “creamy vegetable and cashew curry”, yum right? I stockpiled the hard-to-find ingredients (well for the Catskills anyway) such as curry leaves, black mustard seeds, red chilies and scanned the rest of the list… looked good, the usual suspects going into a curry, garlic, ginger, turmeric etc. Okay, so the “vegetables” in this dish equate mainly to baby new potatoes, shallots and a small red pepper… I can always beef this up by adding chickpeas and cauliflower for more veggie content, no biggie… doo do do dah dah… wow everything looked great…


I put on a pot of basmati rice to accompany my creamy delicious curry…and jazzed that up with a few cardamon pods and a couple of kaffir lime leaves… FANCY PANTS! Okay now I’m really cookin this is just gonna knock their culinary socks off… doo do do doo do… and drum roll please…

ah drums have you started yet? Hmmm needs SALT, yeah no kidding, like everything needs salt, salt brings out flavor…. did I miss something, oh god, did I not follow the recipe? Ah yes I did and there isn’t a granule to be found in this, oh well okay I’ll just throw some in now and give it a big stir, nevermind that it’s already on the table and everyone has started eating…
Sooooo well it’s okay, kinda mild, if you’ve never made a curry before you’d probably like it, I thought it could have used more of pretty much everything and was a bit disappointed because I make my regular Thai curry (recipe coming later) which socks more punch. NEXT…
Now I was really beside myself excited to try out the second recipe.. seeing as I am considered somewhat of an expert on all things Pavlova, Mr Dobson taunted me with a “fresh fig and walnut meringue” hmmm, NOT Pavlova, but worth investigating no less… I was highly skeptical however, knowing the inner workings of the mighty pav, it does NOT take kindly to be messed about with especially the addition of wet fruit into its delicate whipped egg whites and the change of dry sugar to a wetter “packed brown sugar”, BUT it’s NOT a pav and besides the picture looks GORGEOUS AND I found fresh figs…. so there!!

Yum, whipped up egg whites with brown sugar so it’s all melty, caramel colored and luscious looking, here I’m folding in the quartered fresh figs and toasted walnuts and it’s only the fact that this bowl is full of raw eggs that is stopping me from plunging my face straight into it.
HOWEVER…. 45 minutes later, what came out of the oven was (as I secretly, okay and actually verbally predicted to my guests) a soggy, weeping, very unspectacular MESS with a crater the size of the Grand friggin Canyon running through it. Maybe it will taste better than it looks… right?

err NOPE, wow far too sweet, I could feel me teeth rattling in protest with every bite, and the chunky walnuts were also way too much, hey Mr Dobson maybe you wanna run a knife through ‘em?
I didn’t take a shot of IT straight out of the oven, but I did however get the leftover mess of trying to pry these disintegrating pieces off the parchment.

attractive right? Yeah hardly. So folks… what can I tell you… I wasn’t impressed. Sometimes the best things made are the ones whipped up on a whim in the kitchen with nary a thought to an actual “RECIPE” and just because its “written” doesn’t make it good.
And on that note, with my “whipped up recipes” posted here, if any of mine disappoint you or you think they purely SUCK, please don’t hesitate to tell. You know where to find me. Hopefully not with me head in the oven! HAHA.